• Hi Guest !

    Welcome to the 500Eboard forum.

    Since its founding in late 2008, 500Eboard has become the leading resource on the Internet for all things related to the Mercedes-Benz 500E and E500. In recent years, we have also expanded to include the 400E and E420 models, which are directly related to the 500E/E500.

    We invite you to browse and take advantage of the information and resources here on the site. If you find helpful information, please register for full membership, and you'll find even more resources available. Feel free to ask questions, and make liberal use of the "Search" function to find answers.

    We hope you will become an active contributor to the community!

    Sincerely,
    500Eboard Management

M119 crank pulley out of time ?

E420 97 W210

E500E Enthusiast
Member
hi friends, my w210 M119 is malfunctioning as already reported here on the forum, you recommended me to remove the valve cover to see if the timing chain is on time, analyzing the crank pulley I realized that it seems to be out of time, I will attach a photo for everyone's opinion.

if the crank pulley is out of time, has the timing chain skipped a tooth?
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-08-13 à(s) 15.47.32_5101d3a9.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-08-13 à(s) 15.47.32_5101d3a9.jpg
    306.1 KB · Views: 23
How are you checking the crank pulley location / timing? The only valid method is to set the #1 piston at TDC and verifying the pointer aims at the TDC mark on the balancer.

:tumble:
 
How are you checking the crank pulley location / timing? The only valid method is to set the #1 piston at TDC and verifying the pointer aims at the TDC mark on the balancer.
thanks for answering, i didn't do the correct procedure, what is the procedure to leave piston 1 in the correct position, does the pulley have to be at 45c ?

if the crank pulley is at 45c is this a sign that the timing of the timing chain is correct ?
(in which case you wouldn't need to remove the valve cover)

if the crank pulley is at 45c is this a sign that the chain hasn't jumped teeth ?
 
my M119 is faulty, I want to eliminate the possibility that it is a problem with the timing chain, how do I know if it has skipped a tooth or has broken rails ?
 
thanks for answering, i didn't do the correct procedure, what is the procedure to leave piston 1 in the correct position, does the pulley have to be at 45c ?
You'd need to remove the #1 spark plug and insert a long, thin rod through the spark plug hole. A long 3/8" extension works well but any thin, stiff rod will work. rotate the engine and try to figure out when the piston is at TDC (maximum height). The pointer should be close to "0" on the balancer with the piston at TDC.


if the crank pulley is at 45c is this a sign that the timing of the timing chain is correct ?
(in which case you wouldn't need to remove the valve cover)
To check cam timing you must remove both valve covers, rotate the engine and "pin" each camshaft one at a time, and read the number off the balancer. With a new chain and new rails all four should pin at 45° BTDC. With an old chain or broken rails they might be somewhere between 35°-45° BTDC, if so, replace the broken rails first and check again with new rails. "Normal" with an old chain and new rails will be about 40°-45° BTDC.


if the crank pulley is at 45c is this a sign that the chain hasn't jumped teeth ?
If the chain has jumped on any of the sprockets, there will be a large difference in measurement. One tooth = 20° at the crank, so if one camshaft had jumped 1 tooth, that camshaft will read 25° BTDC (or, 15°-25° with broken rails / old chain)... etc.
 
You'd need to remove the #1 spark plug and insert a long, thin rod through the spark plug hole. A long 3/8" extension works well but any thin, stiff rod will work. rotate the engine and try to figure out when the piston is at TDC (maximum height). The pointer should be close to "0" on the balancer with the piston at TDC.



To check cam timing you must remove both valve covers, rotate the engine and "pin" each camshaft one at a time, and read the number off the balancer. With a new chain and new rails all four should pin at 45° BTDC. With an old chain or broken rails they might be somewhere between 35°-45° BTDC, if so, replace the broken rails first and check again with new rails. "Normal" with an old chain and new rails will be about 40°-45° BTDC.



If the chain has jumped on any of the sprockets, there will be a large difference in measurement. One tooth = 20° at the crank, so if one camshaft had jumped 1 tooth, that camshaft will read 25° BTDC (or, 15°-25° with broken rails / old chain)... etc.
Thank you very much for replying, I'll do this procedure and get back to you with the results.
 
You can start on one side and see what the results are, but you really need to check all 4 cams... and inspect ALL the plastic chain rails.

:mushroom:
hi friends, i did the procedure to find out the timing of the crank pulley and got the following result, with cylinder 1 in the highest position, it looked like in the attached photo.

I thought it was a long way from 40-45, would it be too far out of time?
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-08-15 à(s) 09.35.20_26f20277.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-08-15 à(s) 09.35.20_26f20277.jpg
    361.4 KB · Views: 20
hi friends, i did the procedure to find out the timing of the crank pulley and got the following result, with cylinder 1 in the highest position, it looked like in the attached photo.
That looks correct, only a few degrees away from 0 / TDC. The balancer / pointer should be fine.



I thought it was a long way from 40-45, would it be too far out of time?
The 45° BTDC spec is used for checking the camshafts, when pinned as described in the FSM job 05-2230 (click here).

camshaft_pinned_exh1.jpg
 
That looks correct, only a few degrees away from 0 / TDC. The balancer / pointer should be fine.




The 45° BTDC spec is used for checking the camshafts, when pinned as described in the FSM job 05-2230 (click here).

View attachment 197720
thank you very much for replying, so the next step will be to remove the valve cover and check the chain synchronization, is there any special procedure for removing the valve cover?
 
thank you very much for replying, so the next step will be to remove the valve cover and check the chain synchronization,
Correct.


is there any special procedure for removing the valve cover?
No special procedure, but some of the lower bolts may be difficult to access. And, some of the rubber hoses may break when removed, replace them as needed. Make sure to use new copper washers for the bolts when re-installing, along with a new OE/Genuine gasket.

:klink:
 
No special procedure, but some of the lower bolts may be difficult to access. And, some of the rubber hoses may break when removed, replace them as needed. Make sure to use new copper washers for the bolts when re-installing, along with a new OE/Genuine gasket.
One question: does the fact that the engine is turning easily on the crank mean that it hasn't hit any valves or cylinders, or at least minimizes this chance?
 
One question: does the fact that the engine is turning easily on the crank mean that it hasn't hit any valves or cylinders, or at least minimizes this chance?
Very likely, yes. Next step is verifying cam timing (check each of the 4 cams separately, it will require lots of rotating the engine by hand).

You could check compression but if any cylinders are abnormally low, you still need to check cam timing.

:mushroom:
 
hi friends, i did the procedure to find out the timing of the crank pulley and got the following result, with cylinder 1 in the highest position, it looked like in the attached photo.

I thought it was a long way from 40-45, would it be too far out of time?
There's what looks like quite a bit of oil on the pulleys and belt etc which suddenly stops, did you spray anything in that area?

1723742188343.png

@gsxr any comment or pearls of wisdom on that from you?
 
There's what looks like quite a bit of oil on the pulleys and belt etc which suddenly stops, did you spray anything in that area?

@gsxr any comment or pearls of wisdom on that from you?
Good catch - not sure what would cause the liquid. I'm guessing something sprayed or dripped while the belt was in that position for the photo?
 
Good catch - not sure what would cause the liquid. I'm guessing something sprayed or dripped while the belt was in that position for the photo?
It was WD40 spray.

What is the tool used to access the lower valve cover screws?

It's a very tight space.
 
Hello friends, I have some news about the faults on my e420 M119, I removed the valve cover as recommended by you, and found several pieces of chain guide, so we already know the reason for the faults, it really was a broken chain guide, as you can see in the attached photos, I managed to remove a piece of the guide, which guide would that be?

it's just outside the 40º on the crankshaft pulley.
How do I know it hasn't bent the valves?
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.16_2f3315f1.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.16_2f3315f1.jpg
    345.7 KB · Views: 10
  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.16_b4e1757c.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.16_b4e1757c.jpg
    188.3 KB · Views: 10
  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.17_079e0da0.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-02 à(s) 10.57.17_079e0da0.jpg
    318.9 KB · Views: 10
the top guide seems to be whole and the left side guide (facing the engine) seems to be whole, which pieces would be from which guide? right side?
 
To me it looks like the chain guide rail is missing the lower section on both sides. Did the chain guide rails look like that when you took off the valve covers? Or have you unclipped the lower section on both sides?

Have a look at post #2 in the following thread, explaining the remedies to be aware of regarding the chain guide rails:
Post #210 in the same thread has good pics of complete chain guide rails as well:
 
Pic below shows one of the top/center guide rails between the 2 sprockets.

No worry about bent valves unless the cams measure at least 20-25° (likely more) out of time. 5° off spec is nothing to worry about.

1727901665791.png
 
To me it looks like the chain guide rail is missing the lower section on both sides. Did the chain guide rails look like that when you took off the valve covers? Or have you unclipped the lower section on both sides?

Have a look at post #2 in the following thread, explaining the remedies to be aware of regarding the chain guide rails:
Post #210 in the same thread has good pics of complete chain guide rails as well:
thanks for replying, the central chain guide is missing a part compared to the photo of the complete guide obtained here on the forum, and analyzing my guide I noticed that it has a crack at the top, we can conclude that the cause of all these problems is the central chain guide.

Yes, when I removed the valve cover, this part of the guide was missing.

I'm sending you the photos for comparison.
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.43_a085e7df.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.43_a085e7df.jpg
    358.4 KB · Views: 7
  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_28ab74a5.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_28ab74a5.jpg
    349 KB · Views: 7
Pic below shows one of the top/center guide rails between the 2 sprockets.

No worry about bent valves unless the cams measure at least 20-25° (likely more) out of time. 5° off spec is nothing to worry about.

View attachment 199191
thanks for replying, i agree we can conclude that it is the central guide, in comparing the photos i noticed that part of the guide is missing.
What is the procedure for replacing this guide?

posso comprar no ebay um guia original ou de uma marca confiável?
Alguma indicação de uma marca confiável?
Is there any way of upgrading this guide to a metal one or to a more resistant material?

If I replace the guide and put the pulley back in sync, the engine should run normally again, or is there anything else I need to do?
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_28ab74a5.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_28ab74a5.jpg
    349 KB · Views: 0
  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.43_a085e7df.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.43_a085e7df.jpg
    358.4 KB · Views: 0
thanks for replying, the central chain guide is missing a part compared to the photo of the complete guide obtained here on the forum, and analyzing my guide I noticed that it has a crack at the top, we can conclude that the cause of all these problems is the central chain guide.

Yes, when I removed the valve cover, this part of the guide was missing.

I'm sending you the photos for comparison.
I don't know which issues the missing lower section on these guides may cause, if any at all, but another problem is all the pieces from the disintegrated parts spread around in the engine.

From a practical viewpoint, it can't be much load on these chain guide rails, if so they would be torn to pieces in most M119 engines already due to age and brittleness.
 
I don't know which issues the missing lower section on these guides may cause, if any at all, but another problem is all the pieces from the disintegrated parts spread around in the engine.

From a practical viewpoint, it can't be much load on these chain guide rails, if so they would be torn to pieces in most M119 engines already due to age and brittleness.
where it's marked in red, there's a crack in it, probably at some point a chain tooth was knocked out of sync.

Do the pieces that come down go into the oil sump?
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_381bd78b.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-03 à(s) 08.58.44_381bd78b.jpg
    332.5 KB · Views: 1
I don't know which issues the missing lower section on these guides may cause, if any at all, but another problem is all the pieces from the disintegrated parts spread around in the engine.

From a practical viewpoint, it can't be much load on these chain guide rails, if so they would be torn to pieces in most M119 engines already due to age and brittleness.
Wouldn't this missing part of the guide throw the crankshaft out of sync?
 
Wouldn't this missing part of the guide throw the crankshaft out of sync?
Nope. The damaged upper guide between the pulleys will not cause the camshafts to be out of time.

And, per post #11 above, your crankshaft is not out of sync with the pulley / balancer.

Your possible issue is the camshafts out of sync with the crankshaft. Have you checked all 4 camshafts, or only 1? Is 40 degrees the worst offender (only 5 degrees off)? This is a non-issue and pretty much normal for an engine with some broken chain rails. It will not prevent the engine from starting or running. I've seen M119's run with the cams 1 tooth off (20 degrees off spec).
 
Nope. The damaged upper guide between the pulleys will not cause the camshafts to be out of time.

And, per post #11 above, your crankshaft is not out of sync with the pulley / balancer.

Your possible issue is the camshafts out of sync with the crankshaft. Have you checked all 4 camshafts, or only 1? Is 40 degrees the worst offender (only 5 degrees off)? This is a non-issue and pretty much normal for an engine with some broken chain rails. It will not prevent the engine from starting or running. I've seen M119's run with the cams 1 tooth off (20 degrees off spec).
Thank you very much for replying, yes the camshafts are out of sync with the crankshaft, I'll check again to make sure how many degrees are out.

I only checked the camshafts on the cylinder bank where the fault is.
Do I have to check all 4 camshafts?

Wouldn't the broken top rail make the camshafts out of sync?
 
Nope. The damaged upper guide between the pulleys will not cause the camshafts to be out of time.

And, per post #11 above, your crankshaft is not out of sync with the pulley / balancer.

Your possible issue is the camshafts out of sync with the crankshaft. Have you checked all 4 camshafts, or only 1? Is 40 degrees the worst offender (only 5 degrees off)? This is a non-issue and pretty much normal for an engine with some broken chain rails. It will not prevent the engine from starting or running. I've seen M119's run with the cams 1 tooth off (20 degrees off spec).
Any guesses as to what might be causing the fault or why it's out of sync ?
 
I only checked the camshafts on the cylinder bank where the fault is.
Do I have to check all 4 camshafts?
Yes, if ANY cams are out of time, you should check all 4.


Wouldn't the broken top rail make the camshafts out of sync?
No.


Any guesses as to what might be causing the fault or why it's out of sync ?
Most likely there are broken guides below the cam sprockets causing the cams to measure a few degrees out of sync. You must check all the other chain rails.
 
Yes, if ANY cams are out of time, you should check all 4.
Thanks, I'll check.
To check all the chain guides, do I need to open the front of the engine?


Most likely there are broken guides below the cam sprockets causing the cams to measure a few degrees out of sync. You must check all the other chain rails.
What is the procedure for checking these guides below the came sprockets?
 
To check all the chain guides, do I need to open the front of the engine?
No need to open the front of the engine, you can check the chain guides using a flashlight. Search the forum for previous discussion about chain rail replacement.


What is the procedure for checking these guides below the came sprockets?
It's just a visual check from above with good lighting. The most common rails that break are directly below the intake cam sprockets, hard to see without removing the intake cam and/or sprocket.
 
Pic below shows one of the top/center guide rails between the 2 sprockets.

No worry about bent valves unless the cams measure at least 20-25° (likely more) out of time. 5° off spec is nothing to worry about.

View attachment 199191
I rechecked the sync and it seems to be more than 20 degrees off, I did the procedure several times, a curiosity only one cam goes into sync (the 5mm pin fits) the other cam does not stay in sync, in the photos the cam pointed in red the 5mm pin passes only when it is more than 20 degrees off.

I did the procedure several times and it always gave the same result.
 

Attachments

  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-04 à(s) 09.17.56_ad2bcc62.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-04 à(s) 09.17.56_ad2bcc62.jpg
    215.7 KB · Views: 8
  • Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-04 à(s) 09.19.37_4bcc3304.jpg
    Imagem do WhatsApp de 2024-10-04 à(s) 09.19.37_4bcc3304.jpg
    432 KB · Views: 7
I rechecked the sync and it seems to be more than 20 degrees off, I did the procedure several times, a curiosity only one cam goes into sync (the 5mm pin fits) the other cam does not stay in sync, in the photos the cam pointed in red the 5mm pin passes only when it is more than 20 degrees off.

I did the procedure several times and it always gave the same result.
Now I have to worry about possible bent valves ?

What do I have to do to get my e420 running again ?

any suggestions on where to start are welcome
 
Now I have to worry about possible bent valves ?
It's still unlikely, but a simple compression test will tell you if any valves were bent. If any cylinder is abnormally low on compression, a leakdown test may show if it's the valves or not. I would be extremely surprised if there are any bent valves.


What do I have to do to get my e420 running again ?
Replace all the upper chain rails (probably no need to replace either chain rail located down low behind the timing cover), get all 4 camshafts back into sync at 40-45° BTDC. Read post #3 at this link, then read the entire thread.


any suggestions on where to start are welcome
Perform the compression test next, before replacing chain rails or correcting cam timing. Then replace chain rails and fix cam timing, and afterwards repeat the compression test.

Once you have eliminated all mechanical issues related to compression & cam timing & valves, if the engine is still not running properly, it must be related to ignition or fuel delivery.

:v8:
 
It's still unlikely, but a simple compression test will tell you if any valves were bent. If any cylinder is abnormally low on compression, a leakdown test may show if it's the valves or not. I would be extremely surprised if there are any bent valves.



Replace all the upper chain rails (probably no need to replace either chain rail located down low behind the timing cover), get all 4 camshafts back into sync at 40-45° BTDC. Read post #3 at this link, then read the entire thread.



Perform the compression test next, before replacing chain rails or correcting cam timing. Then replace chain rails and fix cam timing, and afterwards repeat the compression test.

Once you have eliminated all mechanical issues related to compression & cam timing & valves, if the engine is still not running properly, it must be related to ignition or fuel delivery.

:v8:
thanks for replying, i'll do the whole procedure and get back to you soon with the results.
 
I rechecked the sync and it seems to be more than 20 degrees off, I did the procedure several times, a curiosity only one cam goes into sync (the 5mm pin fits) the other cam does not stay in sync, in the photos the cam pointed in red the 5mm pin passes only when it is more than 20 degrees off.

I did the procedure several times and it always gave the same result.
A 5mm pin is a bit small and can go in at quite an angle and give a misleading result.

Better to use 6mm like one of the bolts from the valve covers.
 
It's still unlikely, but a simple compression test will tell you if any valves were bent. If any cylinder is abnormally low on compression, a leakdown test may show if it's the valves or not. I would be extremely surprised if there are any bent valves.



Replace all the upper chain rails (probably no need to replace either chain rail located down low behind the timing cover), get all 4 camshafts back into sync at 40-45° BTDC. Read post #3 at this link, then read the entire thread.



Perform the compression test next, before replacing chain rails or correcting cam timing. Then replace chain rails and fix cam timing, and afterwards repeat the compression test.

Once you have eliminated all mechanical issues related to compression & cam timing & valves, if the engine is still not running properly, it must be related to ignition or fuel delivery.

:v8:
Hi friend, are the chain guides I should replace the ones shown in red 6, 8, 14, 16, 26?
or should I just replace guides 6 and 16?

Do you have the part numbers?

i'm thinking of buying the guides from ebay or rockauto (i know they ship to brazil)



I'm thinking of buying a borescope so that I can be sure that the side guides are broken (and really need to be replaced) do you think that with this tool I can analyze the guides without having to remove the sprocket ? (It's a low price tool here)
 

Attachments

  • Captura de tela 2024-10-08 120448.jpg
    Captura de tela 2024-10-08 120448.jpg
    125.8 KB · Views: 12
  • boroscopio.jpg
    boroscopio.jpg
    59.2 KB · Views: 7

Who has viewed this thread (Total: 8) View details

Who has watched this thread (Total: 2) View details

Back
Top