Perhaps some of you remember the "190E or W124 for my 16yr old son" post. I didn't start it but jumped in when my son turned 14. I was looking forward to some father son automotive bonding. He is 16 now and just got his drivers license. Here is what happened.
I eventually purchased a W210 earlier this year, a black on black 2000 E430, for cheap ($3k) with good bones but needed some cosmetic love. I changed the windshield, rear seat leather, trans filter/fluid, diff fluid, spark plugs & wires, rear door panels, right rear door actuator, and completely rejuvenated the 18 year old neglected interior. I even got a paint correction on the outside.

I love it but even though I promised to tint the windows, change to a sport grill (as shown in photo), and put on AMG mono blocks from an E55, my son hated it. He didn't let on at first but as the day for his driver license approached, the car and his feelings towards it just turned into a black hole of misery in the RicardoD household. On the one hand I was struggling with the entitled spoil baby crap my son was throwing at me. You get what you get. I slowly realized I had bought a great car for 16yr old Ricardo and not for my son Alex. I had turned something that was so fundamental to who I am, and something I'd hope to share a bit of with my son, and ruined it. I eventually came home from work one day, and had to let my wife know I made a colossal mistake buying this car, and it was time to cut my losses and move on. I put the car up for sale and sold it 2 days later to a young 20 something kid, with an old soul who respects Grandpa-mobiles, who couldn't believe his luck running into a RicardoD used car, complete with maintenance book, and every single issue taken care of on the car. He will get another 100k miles out of this thing easy. I ended up eating some money as I put more in than the car was worth but I did end up getting those E55 mono blocks that will soon end up my my E500. So it was not a total loss. A big loss of my personal time however and months of un-needed family tension while wrestling with the right thing to do.
So I cut a deal with my kid, lets wipe the slate clean, and start over with a car search the right way, where nothing would be purchased without his consent (or his mother's for that matter).
In 1989 my Dad bought me a used 1981 BMW 320i when I was in my late teens. I love that car and it got me all the way through graduate school.

I eventually ended up doing the same thing for my son as my Dad did for me. I found a 8 year old 2010 BMW 328i coupe. Metallic gray but with saddle brown interior. M-sports suspension option. Just like my Dad bought me back in the day but this car is light years better.

So yes, I have a spoiled kid, but he is happy, and more importantly, we got the car on the lift this weekend, he changed the oil by himself enthusiastically (can't suck it out from the top like my E500), and also polished and detailed it. Here he is doing the synthetic clay bar treatment before I went at it with the polisher.

Now his friends are driving too, and word is spreading there is a great DIY garage is at Alex's Dad's house and I am getting asked to help with transmission service on an Audi next weekend. So that makes me happy that my garage time fun is intersecting my kids world and glad to help out the youngsters learn how to take care of their cars. Automotive harmony has returned to my house hold and my 14 year old younger son is happy he won't end up with an old Mercedes grandpa mobile like his older brother (I offered to buy him Bill Sutton's Silver E500 but he declined! Haha).
I eventually purchased a W210 earlier this year, a black on black 2000 E430, for cheap ($3k) with good bones but needed some cosmetic love. I changed the windshield, rear seat leather, trans filter/fluid, diff fluid, spark plugs & wires, rear door panels, right rear door actuator, and completely rejuvenated the 18 year old neglected interior. I even got a paint correction on the outside.

I love it but even though I promised to tint the windows, change to a sport grill (as shown in photo), and put on AMG mono blocks from an E55, my son hated it. He didn't let on at first but as the day for his driver license approached, the car and his feelings towards it just turned into a black hole of misery in the RicardoD household. On the one hand I was struggling with the entitled spoil baby crap my son was throwing at me. You get what you get. I slowly realized I had bought a great car for 16yr old Ricardo and not for my son Alex. I had turned something that was so fundamental to who I am, and something I'd hope to share a bit of with my son, and ruined it. I eventually came home from work one day, and had to let my wife know I made a colossal mistake buying this car, and it was time to cut my losses and move on. I put the car up for sale and sold it 2 days later to a young 20 something kid, with an old soul who respects Grandpa-mobiles, who couldn't believe his luck running into a RicardoD used car, complete with maintenance book, and every single issue taken care of on the car. He will get another 100k miles out of this thing easy. I ended up eating some money as I put more in than the car was worth but I did end up getting those E55 mono blocks that will soon end up my my E500. So it was not a total loss. A big loss of my personal time however and months of un-needed family tension while wrestling with the right thing to do.
So I cut a deal with my kid, lets wipe the slate clean, and start over with a car search the right way, where nothing would be purchased without his consent (or his mother's for that matter).
In 1989 my Dad bought me a used 1981 BMW 320i when I was in my late teens. I love that car and it got me all the way through graduate school.

I eventually ended up doing the same thing for my son as my Dad did for me. I found a 8 year old 2010 BMW 328i coupe. Metallic gray but with saddle brown interior. M-sports suspension option. Just like my Dad bought me back in the day but this car is light years better.

So yes, I have a spoiled kid, but he is happy, and more importantly, we got the car on the lift this weekend, he changed the oil by himself enthusiastically (can't suck it out from the top like my E500), and also polished and detailed it. Here he is doing the synthetic clay bar treatment before I went at it with the polisher.

Now his friends are driving too, and word is spreading there is a great DIY garage is at Alex's Dad's house and I am getting asked to help with transmission service on an Audi next weekend. So that makes me happy that my garage time fun is intersecting my kids world and glad to help out the youngsters learn how to take care of their cars. Automotive harmony has returned to my house hold and my 14 year old younger son is happy he won't end up with an old Mercedes grandpa mobile like his older brother (I offered to buy him Bill Sutton's Silver E500 but he declined! Haha).
Last edited: