It's exceedingly rare that folks have felt un-welcome on this forum. I have seen a couple of other cases (even very recently) where feelings have been hurt because peoples' cars have been strongly and brutally critiqued.But I spoke to Mosselmann on phone after that discussion and he didn't feel welcome on this forum, so he will hardly return here again. I understand him because he was not met with much enthusiasm from all here. I think someone became jealous on his car. Read post #53, last sentence, and research why he said that.
While I don't condone (and will not tolerate) any form of outright/blatant nastiness, I CERTAINLY welcome strong critiques of cars posted for sale or discussed, particularly if the critique is done factually and without the intent of personally attacking the owner of the car. And that's the line, that I really have yet to see crossed here - I have not seen anyone really PERSONALLY ATTACKED and put down. Cars critiqued yes, peoples' personalities no.
The "rub" is when an owner is extremely emotionally attached to their car, and receives/processes/accepts criticism of their car as a personal attack on them. While we are all human and it is easy to do this, in my experience the criticism has not been intended as a personal attack. If a member does perceive a personal attack, I urge them to contact myself or a fellow Site Admin (GSXR, Glen, Jelmer) directly and double-check their perception, discuss the offence, and consider a response together with the Site Admin or at minimum with a fellow trusted site member/friend.
While no one likes to have their car attacked and harshly criticized, it is a fact of life that when one displays their car on a public forum, that criticism and questions are inevitably going to result, and not necessarily to the person's liking. If someone comes onto a forum and displays their car, and doesn't have much "enthusiasm" or as positive of a response as they would like or had expected, that is 100% THEIR PROBLEM ... NOT the problem of the members here.
Bottom line is to play in a public sandbox, you have to have a thick skin.
On the flip side to this ... we do have a few members who are consistently harsh and [perhaps, a bit] voiciferous in their "commentary" on cars. Perhaps just a smidge of temperance on this could help lubricate things a bit better. I am NOT condoning people to be soft and artificially nice to each other and others' cars all the time, but perhaps a bit of moderation in the choice of words used and/or tone could help avoid hurt feelings and bruised egos.
A big exception to this is when sellers (whether members or not) pump up their cars and grossly exaggerate their condition, trying to pawn off a terd as a diamond. In those cases, criticism (although subjective) is certainly warranted, as long as personal attacks are avoided. For reference, I don't consider statements like "Man, the weed crop in California must be hella good this year for that guy to be asking that sort of price for that wreck" (or similar statement) to be a personal attack with malicious intent.
The bottom line is that perhaps some folks need to grow thicker skins, and temper their expectations a bit as to how "kingly" they will be treated when they show up with a nice car, and others need to just be a slight bit nicer in HOW (not WHAT) they say things.

Cheers,
Gerry
