Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
@agsiress - The video from the first message in this thread is likely the best all around video I've found of the sound characteristics. Here is the youtube link as well:
I am following this closely to see the resolution! I have JC’s beautiful catalyst.... the exit pipes of the catalyst are made the same way as @IslandMon your test pipe .... and I am also hoping to bolt it onto the sam OE center resonator.....although I have not tried yet....Started installing the front section and test pipe today. I am still using the center and rear mufflers. It doesn’t look like the clamp fitting has enough room to slide on the new pipe before it hits the fresh weld.
@5thscaleracer what am I missing? View attachment 131052View attachment 131053View attachment 131054
Yes, one pipe on the resonator is flared, the other accepts the smooth pipe of test pipe. With the clamp on the new test pipe smooth section, I can’t push the two pieces together all of the way because the weld on the new test pipe bottoms out on the clamp, leaving a gap bigger than the sealing ring at the flared pipes.Note one of the center resonator input pipes are flared .... is yours flared the same way? It is kind of hard for me to tell .... like has your old center resonator been modified or is it just rusty crustiness that is blocking JC’s testpipe from sliding in?
Hmmmm.... I think we need @5thscaleracer, when he has a chance, to tell us what the right approach is.I always thought the Flieben front section was designed to work specifically with the Flieben rear section... and it wasn't meant to be compatible with OE middle muffler/resonator. However, if the weld was either ground flat or relocated a few inches further upstream, it might be ok.
Note the Flieben rear section does not use the same type of connection on the slip-fit pipe, i.e. no graphite ring with compression flange as on the OE middle section. The Flieben slip-fit connection uses an external clamp.
Photo below from the 2019 thread, post #70 at this link.
View attachment 131070
Same. Otherwise, why would anyone buy just a front section? Unless they were planning on having a custom resonator/muffler made that wasn't fliebenI thought in the 2019 thread that the Fleiben front section and [catalysts or testpipe] were supposed to work with the factory resonator and rear exhaust ----
Here from the 2019 thread: Post #14
@Jlaa you posted an image of a new resonatorI am following this closely to see the resolution! I have JC’s beautiful catalyst.... the exit pipes of the catalyst are made the same way as @IslandMon your test pipe .... and I am also hoping to bolt it onto the sam OE center resonator.....although I have not tried yet....
@IslandMon .... here is a pic of the catalyst I got from JC as well as my new center resonator. Note one of the center resonator input pipes are flared .... is yours flared the same way? It is kind of hard for me to tell .... like has your old center resonator been modified or is it just rusty crustiness that is blocking JC’s testpipe from sliding in?
@Jlaa you posted an image of a new resonator
take a look at the area that have been circled see how the “donut cup” is followed by an expanded area then it steps down to its true pipe diameter.
my test pipe or catalyst extension. Will slip into this position.
@IslandMon take a look at this.
could it have been repaired? i really don't know we used a 1992 and 1993 500e both had the factory exhaust and we did several test fits of both front and rear section before offering the kits.Yeah, that's fascinating, thanks @5thscaleracer. The new resonator picture that I posted is the picture of a new resonator that I bought in 2017 and had installed on my car. Blowing up @IslandMon's resonator picture and my resonator picture, the "donut cup" area looks different. I wonder why. I note that the Eberspacher numbers are seemingly the same.
View attachment 131092
@5thscaleracer My factory resonator does have the stepped section you are referring to. The step is just underneath the flange in the picture. The pipe from your test pipe slides right in, but the weld on the test pipe prevents it from sliding in far enough for the flared side to meet the flared side of the resonator.@IslandMon, if you move that flange, can you see a "pipe step"?
Let me search for test fit images because iirc the flange was not meant to go past that weld spot.@5thscaleracer My factory resonator does have the stepped section you are referring to. The step is just underneath the flange in the picture. The pipe from your test pipe slides right in, but the weld on the test pipe prevents it from sliding in far enough for the flared side to meet the flared side of the resonator.
I didn't push it all the way together in the photo because I knew it wouldn't go all the way in, and didn't want to have to have to struggle pulling it apart for no reason.
@gsxr is probably right - if the weld is ground down, the flange should be able to slide past it (farther towards the front of the test pipe) so that the sections can be fully mated together.
It does look like if the weld was ground smooth, it should work. Do you normally clean that weld up/ grind it? I am not positive that the flange will slide past it because the tubing OD gets slightly larger past that weld, but can grind down the weld to try.Let me search for test fit images because iirc the flange was not meant to go past that weld spot.
I hope I still have them as this was done back in 2014
Hello @5thscaleracer! Thank you so much for the candor!@IslandMon and @Jlaa it looks like I made a mistake in stating that these are backwards compatible.
I confirmed with Matt from Leistung Autohaus.
We never did the test fit of the new front section with factory resonator. The original design was to only offer the front section with upgraded rears.
That being said I am more than happy to do a return on these parts including shipping.
The other option which I am willing to cover the expense. Have a muffler shop cut that pipe [on the Fleiben catalyst/test pipe assembly] 3-4” past that weld and replace with a smaller OD pipe that slips into the resonator.
This will allow the Oe flange to sit further back so it can fit further into the recess.
send me a copy of the invoice and I will refund the difference.
Third option
I can do the modifications here in CA but it would take two weeks to get these made and we exchange parts.
Return the old parts with the supplied call tag/box.
So in order to make the Test pipe or Catalyst become compatible with either Stock or Flieben rear exhaust that one modification would need to take place.Hello @5thscaleracer! Thank you so much for the candor!
I am inclined to take you up on your offer to go for the third option but let me please first explain my thinking.
The reason I purchased the Flieben front section + catalyst was because:
Would it be possible for you to modify the Flieben catalyst I have with a removeable couple-inches-of-pipe that allows the catalyst to work with both the factory resonator and the Flieben rear exhaust? [If yes then I would have to go ahead and purchase the Flieben turned-down-tip rear exhaust as well].
- My current front section + catalyst is OE from 1993.
- My current resonator and rear exhaust are new MB parts from 2017.
- I would run the Fleiben front section + catalyst with my 2017 resonator+exhaust until at some point I would replace my 2017 MB resonator+Exhaust with the Flieben turned-down-tip-rear exhaust. So it was the promise of interchangeability in the future that was attractive to me.
Thanks!
- @Jlaa
UPDATEClarification with images.
the modification to make this all work would be to make 1 cut and extend the smaller OD pipe back.
This will allow the factory clamp to sit further back and everything will work.
Send me your info ASAP 5thscaleracer@verizon.netGreat to hear how good his customer service is. I have the front section too sitting in a corner and my plan was to mate it up to the stock resonator and muffler which I was under the impression would be fine. I'll get a couple pics and send them over to 5thscaleracer and see what solution we can come up with. Planning to get the car on a lift next week and can start comparing.
By the way, I have a non-catted front section - would love to trade/pay up for a catted front section if anyone interested or any available